Featured Blogs - Subscribe to Free Blog

A DaVinci Code In Department of Interior Order On Energy Project “Capacity Density”
I found this interesting about the new Order issued by the Department of the Interior (DOI) on use of federal lands for energy projects: “the Department shall consider energy projects’ capacity density in its decision-making, including when considering reasonable alternatives...

German Government Gives Initial Nod to CCS/CCU
Here’s some carbon news from Clean Energy Wire: “The German government cabinet has approved a draft law that would allow the underground storage of CO2 and enable its large-scale transport through pipelines, and thus pave the way for the application...

New This Week on PracticalESG.com
Notable additions to PracticalESG.com this week are below. Blogs of the week: It was another close one – Our Research Is Complete: How Financial Value of Sustainability Is Disclosed (or Not) by Over 110 US Companies, and Florida AG Investigates...

EFRAG Publishes Exposure Drafts for New Scaled Down ESRS
The EU’s Omnibus simplification efforts hit another milestone as EFRAG completed their work on the new European Sustainability Reporting Standards (ESRS). As part of the EU’s efforts to scale back mandatory sustainability reporting, the EU Commission ordered EFRAG to overhaul...

Judge Denies BlackRock’s Motion to Dismiss in Texas Antitrust Case
BlackRock, State Street, and Vanguard have battled an antitrust case in Texas since last year. Earlier this summer, BlackRock filed a Motion to Dismiss in the litigation. Despite the asset manager’s capitulation and withdrawal from the Net Zero Asset Managers...

Sustainable Packaging Initiatives Aren’t Working
Sustainability Magazine had some unwelcome news recently: “Research and advisory firm Gartner predicts that by 2028, 75% of organisations will relinquish their voluntary sustainable packaging objectives and follow just compulsory legislative standards. While companies like Walmart and Unilever set ambitious...

Florida AG Investigates CDP and SBTi over Antitrust Concerns
Anti-ESG has an unorthodox playbook of courtroom strategies. Antitrust is one that has long raised eyebrows among legal experts. While these theories haven’t seen success in the courtroom yet, with only one case being filed in Texas, they are proliferating....

EU Carbon Offset Investigation Targets Specific Employees at Verification Bodies
It has been a minute, so I’m going to write about another carbon offset project scandal – or at least regulatory investigation. This time, it’s personal. Not for me, but for staff at verification bodies. Bloomberg reported “Luxembourg authorities are...

Italy’s Authorities Crack Down on Fashion Industry’s Sustainability Claims
Italian regulators handed down two enforcement actions related to sustainability at companies in – what else?… the fashion and clothing industry. France24 reported that Italy’s competition regulator “fined the company responsible for Shein’s websites in Europe one million euros ($1.15...

Our Research Is Complete: How Financial Value of Sustainability Is Disclosed (or Not) by Over 110 US Companies
Just over a year ago, I began planning a research project to analyze how (or if) companies formally disclose financial gains/ROI of sustainability initiatives and investments. In the intervening months, project details changed somewhat and today the initial draft is...

Beyond Our New Research – Is Sustainability More Than Financial ROI?
I’m certainly excited about our new research on how US companies report financial benefits of sustainability programs. However, my view on the need for an ROI/financial value supporting corporate sustainability programs sometimes comes under fire for taking too narrow a...

New This Week on PracticalESG.com
Notable additions to PracticalESG.com this week are below. Blog of the week: SEC Commissioner Crenshaw Slams SEC’s Update on Climate Disclosure Rule 12 new CSRD reports were added this week which can be viewed here. Hot Topics for the Week:...

A Good Sustainability Business Case Is a Good Legal Defense
Anti-ESG has been busy, and more states are passing and enforcing anti-ESG laws. One of the core arguments used by anti-ESG is that by focusing on ESG factors, companies are diminishing financial returns – a breach of fiduciary duty. The...

Sustainability Report Assurance Popularity Poses Issues for Audit Committees
Advisory Board member and former Chair PCAOB Chair Dan Goelzer offered commentary recently on the popularity of assurance of sustainability reports and what Audit Committees should be thinking about in that regard. He suggests four specific aspects of sustainability report...

Italian Government Enforces Worker Rights at Another Luxury Brand
Luxury brands have faced increasing public pressure concerning worker conditions in supplier facilities. The Business & Human Rights Resource Centre reported that “luxury clothing company Loro Piana (part of LVMH) has been put on judicial administration over the abuse of...

Two International Courts Issue Advisory Opinions on Climate Change
Two international courts issued advisory opinions on the obligations of states to respond to climate change. On July 3, the Inter-American Court of Human Rights published an opinion finding that States have an obligation to mitigate climate change through policies...

Anti-ESG Pushback Isn’t Slowing Down
Trellis wrote lasts week: “70 percent of experts say there’s a significant backlash against the sustainability agenda in their country, up 13 percentage points from 2024. North America is most polarized, with nine in ten experts reporting significant backlash compared...

Could ESG Litigation Break Containment?
The US doesn’t lead in many ESG areas. When it comes to emissions trading, climate reporting, and supply chain management, the US regulatory scheme is lagging or nonexistent. However, the US does prevail in one major area: litigation. I wrote...

SEC Commissioner Crenshaw Slams SEC’s Update on Climate Disclosure Rule
Yesterday, SEC Commission Caroline Crenshaw issued a harsh rebuke of action taken by her fellow Commissioners in a status update in the ongoing litigation concerning the Climate-Related Disclosure Rules: “The Court [the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit]...

Supreme Court Allows Environmental Citizen Suits to Stand
Recent Supreme Court decisions rocked the federal agencies and limited their ability to promulgate new environmental regulations. From the creation of the new Major Questions Doctrine in West Virginia v. EPA to the overturning of Chevron Deference in Loper Bright,...

New This Week on PracticalESG.com
Notable additions to PracticalESG.com this week are below. Blog of the week: Anti-ESG Bills Sweep in 13 Red States new CSRD reports were added this week which can be viewed here. Hot Topics for the Week: “State of the Profession,”...

Interior Cuts Red Tape on Plugging Abandoned Oil & Gas Wells And …
Last week, the Department of the Interior announced an update of “its guidelines for states applying to federal programs aimed at cleaning up abandoned oil and gas wells.” “The revised guidance eliminates non-statutory requirements and reduces burdens on State grant...

… Eliminates Incentives, Support for Wind and Solar Projects
While were talking about Department of the Interior… they also announced an end to “preferential treatment for unreliable, subsidy-dependent wind and solar energy.” “The Department of the Interior is ending preferential treatment for unreliable, subsidy-dependent wind and solar energy. The...

Research Finds Auto Industry is Stalling Out on Climate Goals
We know you keep hearing it – sustainability in the US is facing a challenging moment. The federal deregulatory landscape, along with political backlash, often pits promises made years ago against the present reality. Some have publicly walked away from...

Private Markets: Sustainability Teams Show “Bright Line Connections to Bottom and Top Lines”
In recent months, popular media has sensationalized the death of ESG/sustainability due to anti-ESG populism and a new US federal government deregulatory, anti-ESG agenda. But those headlines are only true to an extent, although moreso for those who believe that...

White House Proclamations Extend NESHAPs Compliance Dates Two Years for Four Industries
Last week, the White House issued multiple proclamations exempting coal-fired power plants, synthetic organic chemical manufacturers, medical equipment sterilization operations using ethylene oxide and taconite iron ore processing from previously promulgated EPA NESHAPs compliance standards. Each of the proclamations uses...

Ombudsman Seeks Clarification on Omnibus Process
The EU’s Omnibus reforms have been divisive. While some believe the reforms reduce unnecessary burdens on industry, others think they are the result of unchecked lobbying. Previously, we wrote about a group of NGOs that filed a complaint with the...

EU To Strengthen Carbon Capture Permanence Criteria
This is good news I think. Bloomberg reports that “The European Union is set to define what technologies can be used to permanently remove carbon dioxide from the atmosphere as it pursues its goal of being climate neutral by 2050....

Anti-ESG Bills Sweep in 13 Red States
Anti-ESG continues to have some success in 2025, winning allies at the federal level and seeing a slew of states pass laws related to ESG investing. Laws prohibiting or discouraging ESG investing have been a staple of the anti-ESG movement...

New This Week on PracticalESG.com
Notable additions to PracticalESG.com this week are below. Blog of the week: The New Sustainability Reporting Trend: Not Reporting 16 new CSRD reports were added this week which can be viewed here. Hot Topics for the Week: “GHG Baseline Restatement...

EU Commission Adopts CSRD “Quick Fix” for Phase 1 Companies
Reduction in scope is core to the EU’s Omnibus package for CSRD. If things proceed as expected, we’ll see an 80% reduction in in-scope companies, with many wave 1 companies falling out of scope. When the omnibus proposal was initially...

UK Abandons Development of Green Taxonomy
Back in February, we explored the possibility of the UK nixing its Green Taxonomy after closing a public consultation on the regulation. Now, following a review of public comments, the UK government confirmed that indeed it will not pursue a...

VCMI Not Getting Traction Due to Lack of Market Confidence in … What?
The last couple years have seen enough scandals in the voluntary carbon offset world to lose count. Yet voluntary carbon market (VCM) developers, certifiers and investors continued to be upbeat. Yesterday, however, Responsible Investor reported the most tangible evidence that...

Sustainability Has Never Been Stronger Than It Is Now – But Are Your Prepared?
If you only read headlines, then you are probably pessimistic about the state of corporate sustainability right now. Regulatory pullbacks and delays, weaponization of DEI, inadequate progress on emissions reductions/targets, carbon offset scandals – these are the stuff of most...

ESMA Issues Thematic Note on ESG Credentials
While the European Commission, Parliament, and Council may be delaying and scaling back ESG laws, EU regulators are still moving on enforcement and guidance. Recently, the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) issued new guidance for financial firms making sustainability...

T-Mobile Scraps DEI in Anticipation of Regulatory Approvals – Only Not Really
Maybe you saw the headlines last week that T-Mobile is ending its DEI program “as it awaits regulatory approval from the Federal Communications Commission for two acquisition deals.” T-Mobile’s letter to the FCC said the company would end its DEI...

The New Sustainability Reporting Trend: Not Reporting
[Ed. note – We’d really be grateful if you would take 5 seconds to respond to this LinkedIn poll. It doesn’t ask for your information and it isn’t a sales pitch. Thank you.] Wow – this was pretty shocking. Yesterday,...

Greenwashing Enforcement Still a Global Priority
[Ed. note – We’d really be grateful if you would take 5 seconds to respond to this LinkedIn poll. It doesn’t ask for your information and it isn’t a sales pitch. Thank you.] While the US is unlikely to take...

New This Week on PracticalESG.com
Notable additions to PracticalESG.com this week are below. Blog of the week: 2025 SEC Filings Show Major Change in Climate Language No new CSRD reports were added his week but our library can be viewed here. Hot Topics for the...

EU Commission Imposes Materiality Threshold on Taxonomy
As part of the EU’s widespread efforts to simplify sustainability regulations, we’ve seen many landmark sustainability laws revisited. Among these is the EU Taxonomy, a law designed to classify sustainable economic activities and direct investment toward them. The European Commission...

Wind & Solar Tax Credits Axed by EO; CCUS Tax Credits Reduced by OBBB Act
Well, there it is… Monday, The White House issued a new EO Ending Market Distorting Subsidies For Unreliable, Foreign Controlled Energy Sources. The meat of it: “Within 45 days following enactment of the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, the Secretary...

Coal-Based Scope 2 Emissions Set to Increase
Coal-based energy production got a boost from investors globally in 2024 after a dip during 2023 according to Bloomberg. “Global banks channeled more than $385 billion to the coal power industry over the past three years, with annual flows increasing...

EU to Exclude 90% of Companies from CBAM
The CSRD isn’t the only sustainability regulation undergoing “simplification” in the EU. A number of other regulations are being addressed through omnibus proposals, including the Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM). CBAM was designed to apply an embedded carbon tax on...

Financial Times: Chinese Trans-Shipments Through Viet Nam Try to Avoid US Tariffs
Recently, John and I blogged about the increasing risk of regulatory enforcement against companies that try to avoid the new US tariffs. The Financial Times wrote that companies are already trying this tactic: “Chinese businesses are sending increasing volumes of...

Companies Change DEI Talk in Proxy Statements
I’ll admit it right off the bat – this blog is straight from John at TheCorporateCounsel.net. There isn’t a way to be more clear and concise: “Winston & Strawn looked at 2025 Fortune 100 proxy filings, and their recent blog...
Featured Events
- AI in ESG
- Agricultural Sector
- Air Emissions
- Anti-ESG
- B Corporation
- Biodiversity
- Board Oversight of E&S Issues
- Board Oversight of E&S Issues / M&A Considerations
- Bonded Labor
- CBAM
- CSRD
- Carbon Management
- Chemical Use
- Chief Sustainability Officers
- Circular Economy
- Climate
- Climate / Emissions / Offsets
- Climate Bonds
- Clothing/Textiles Sector
- Companies Changing ESG Commitments
- Company ESG Reports
- Compliance / Enforcement / Litigation
- Data Centers
- Deforestation
- Disclosing ESG Performance
- E&S Data Verification, Assurance & Auditors
- E&S Governance
- ESG Business Value
- ESG Disclosures / Reporting
- ESG Financial Impact
- ESG Issues by Industry Sector
- ESG Ratings
- ESG Ratings Agencies
- ESG Staffing Matters
- Electronics / Technology Sector
- Energy Sector
- Enforcement
- Financial Services Sector
- GHGs
- Green Bonds
- Greenwashing
- Healthcare
- Hot Topics
- International ESG Standard Setting Organizations
- International Trade/Supply Chain/Social Risk
- Investor Perspectives on ESG Performance
- Investor Policies & Trends / Shareholder Activism & Engagement / Shareholder Proposals
- Investor Trends
- Just Transition
- Legal Services Sector
- Litigation
- M&A Considerations
- Materiality in ESG Performance Disclosure
- Offsets
- Plastics
- Private Companies
- Product Labels
- Public Benefit Corporation
- Real Estate Sector
- Retail Sector
- Reuse / Recycling
- Risk Management
- Semiconductors Sector
- Shareholder Activism
- Shareholder Engagement
- Shareholder Proposals
- Social Audits
- Social Risk
- Supply Chain
- Sustainability-linked Bonds
- Sustainable Finance/Bonds
- Trafficking & Slavery
- Transportation Sector
- Waste Management
- Water & Wastewater Issues
- Water Bonds
- Water Issues/Freshwater/ Ocean Health/ Wastewater
Featured Q&A Members Only
Extent to which diversity must be discussed in proxy statement
It is my understanding that the only requirement as to diversity left for the proxy at this time is in relation to whether the nominating committee considers diversity in selecting directors. If a company, at the last minute out of concern of anti-DEI sentiment, changes its nominating committee charter to remove all reference to considering diversity when selecting directors, does it still need to mention diversity in the proxy as to selecting directors since the charter still spoke of diversity during the past fiscal year?
It appears that under the rule, a company is required to address in the proxy whether it considers diversity among its director nominees, and if so, how it considers diversity. This would appear to indicate that even if a company is concerned over anti DEI sentiment, it still needs to address diversity in the proxy, in terms or whether and how it considers it, even if it is considered in a way that does not involve race or gender.
It is still unclear to me whether a company that updates its charter at the last minute to remove all reference to race and gender in diversity can represent on the proxy that it does not consider race and gender in its diversity assessment. However it is my understanding that because proxies are forward looking, this may be acceptable.
It has also come to my attention that Glass Lewis issued a statement that it is sticking to its diversity expectations unlike ISS. Does this mean that a company that no longer requires race or gender as part of a diversity assessment risks a negative recommendation from GL?
07/8/2025, Question #29424
Removing DEI from SEC 10-Ks
Are companies being advised to not discuss DEI in their 10-Ks due to the executive orders? If a company previously mentioned having a diversity policy and its diversity workforce statistics, is that going to create an issue to now remove them?
05/5/2025, Question #28369
CDP Disclosure Insight Action
We recently received a letter from CDP Disclosure Insight Action requesting that we disclose certain environmental information through their questionnaire. From what I can tell, this is not required and, as we currently disclose sustainability related information in many different places and to many different people, we’re not inclined to voluntarily add another to the list. However, I was curious what other companies who received this letter intend to do. Would appreciate your thoughts here.
04/15/2025, Question #27998