One day after initial reports were due under SB 253, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals issued a major decision impacting California climate reporting. While the decision doesn’t touch Scope 1 and 2 reporting as currently required under SB 253, it does have other serious implications. SB 253 includes phase-in requirements for Scope 3 data. The Court’s Opinion throws the future of that phase-in into doubt. A recent Ropes & Gray memo discusses the Opinion, stating:
“The panel held that, because SB 253’s Scope 3 disclosures concern diffuse third-party conduct in the value chain, they are insufficiently tethered to the reporting entity’s own operations and capital transactions to qualify as commercial speech. As such, this provision is subject to strict scrutiny, which it fails. Because SB 253’s Scope 3 disclosure provisions are likely unconstitutional, the panel remanded to the District Court to determine, in the first instance, whether those provisions are severable.”
This likely pushes Scope 3 reporting out significantly as the courts continue to assess its constitutionality. The Opinion suggests that Scope 3 reporting is unlikely to materialize on the grounds that it constitutes compelled speech. Additionally, the Opinion also holds implications for SB 261, California’s climate risk reporting law. SB 261 has been enjoined by the Ninth Circuit since shortly after its passage. The Court’s recent Opinion applies a strict scrutiny standard to SB 261. This means California has a high legal bar to clear. For the foreseeable future, it looks like Scope 1 and 2 reporting under SB 253 are the limits of California’s power. SB 253’s Scope 1 and 2 requirements seem relatively safe, while Scope 3 and climate-related risk reporting under SB 261 may never come into effect.
Our members can learn more about climate disclosure laws here.
